Scott,
I say keep the Sport because I'm an off road poser and claim to off road 6 months out of the year during the Canadian winters. Now, if I was in your shoes, with the amount of off-roading you do I would ask myself; "Which vehicle is more reliable long term and can handle the punishment?" I absolutely HATE the look of any Jeep but I hear that they are quite reliable. Note that I have NEVER sat in or had any experience in owning or being friends with an owner of a Jeep so take that with a grain of salt
I say keep the Sport because I'm an off road poser and claim to off road 6 months out of the year during the Canadian winters. Now, if I was in your shoes, with the amount of off-roading you do I would ask myself; "Which vehicle is more reliable long term and can handle the punishment?" I absolutely HATE the look of any Jeep but I hear that they are quite reliable. Note that I have NEVER sat in or had any experience in owning or being friends with an owner of a Jeep so take that with a grain of salt