So I did some tinkering and I think I've narrowed down where the problem lies. I took some of the console off and saw that the wire attached to the break lever had a pinch in it that was preventing it from going into the hole. Instead it was bending, which is why the lever would not stay secure in the off position. I can't seem to be able to force it in there, so at this point I wonder if there is another way to disengage it. Here are a couple pics that might be able to help.
E-brake in the "off" position.
Wire that is bending, preventing the brake to disengage. I am holding it from where it secures to the lever.
E-brake in the "off" position.

Wire that is bending, preventing the brake to disengage. I am holding it from where it secures to the lever.
